What 5 maps would you miss the least?

[Alakazou]

Oh, come on both of you. Knoffhoff just asks a question for his personal deeds. Don't think that there will be some big design change because of it. It's good that testers and devs ask things like that to check if they're not too much detached from the community and it's opinion. And I think that asking people visiting this forum is best way to get a hang of things. The atentive players are most loyal and therefore most important for game development in long term.

I can't choose because I love them all. But if people don't love some map, It's good to read them about what they hate or what they want to change

[Smiles]

The maps id like to play the least:

Mount Olympus

The things i enjoyed where AA and AT. Its to repetitive and there are almost no fun inbetween battle times.

Mersa Matruh

Played it way to much before the Normandy patch + people lost/havnt learned the tactics wich work and noone seems to bother<-- imo almost all Africa maps play out differently now than before, dont think this map has been altered.

Anctoville.

Rapefest.

[Captain Pyjama Shark]

I would be so happy if Goodwood was never played again, I can't remember ever really having fun on it and I swear it is on 24/7.

Ramelle, on the other hand, is probably the most fun map IMO.

[Torenico]

I seem to be one of the few guys that likes Aberdeen and Bardia...

I'll make it short now, All Infantry maps, some a art, others are pure fragfest. I cant stand these maps, because of the European Servers beign everywhere, imagine playing a Infantry only map with 250ms, cant play it.

So my vote goes for all Infantry maps.








And Goodwood. And Falaise. End.

[Capten_C]

No qualms...in order of hatredness

Bardia
Olympus
Aberdeen
Tunis
Gazala

Olympus is a beautifull map but the gameplay is erratic, distant, and drags..

Sidi Rezegeh is also a beautifull map..but the bleed needs sorting and perhaps 1 more Axis tank of worth to begin with    Then it becomes awsome Afrika map  

[General_Henry]

I could only have 4 choice, I find something worth keeping in the rest


1. Operation Aberdeen

Definitely not the kind of tank map, it is just a matter of luck that whether your tank shell hit the critical parts of the enemy tank. Map design doesn't feel war-like.


2. El Alamein

A map that is more suited for 128 players. Definitely not for FH.


3. Olympus

A map with no special feature other than the castle which is just slightly more interesting. (and often get ignored)


4. Operation Totalize

Another map without the feeling of war. More like a map to show you all the toys of FH2.2

[hslan.totaler_humbug]

Totalize: because everyone likes it, it will get played anyways. No teamplay at all

All other maps are some kind of special in their own way. I really like all maps and I love to play them all!

Edit: Most other maps posted here are one of my favorite maps: Aberdeen, El Al, Supercharge, Olympus, Gazala, Goodwood, Anctoville

[Wilhelm]

I don't hate any of the maps in the mod, but these are the ones that I least like to play.


Supercharge: The gameplay seems too "messy" to me.

Operation Luttich: Probably my least favorite map in the mod.  I never feel like playing it; I just don't like the "feeling" of the map for some reason (aka, the way it is set up and the light settings).

Villers-Bocage: I have some fun on this map, but as with Luttich I just don't like the "feeling" of it.




Aberdeen: I actually didn't vote for it because I clicked the submit button too soon!    As for why I dislike it, just look at any of the reasons mentioned previously in this thread.

Mersa Matruh:   I didn't vote for this one either, but I dislike it.  I find it boring most of the time.

[NuclearHendrix]

Siege of Giarabub, Mareth Line, Bardia, and Operation Totalize... A 5th wasn't necessary .

[Natty]

Brilliant thread...

I had four maps I didn't even have to think 10sec to click the boxes in the poll for:
Aberdeen: because I don't like its game play and think it is ugly and quite sloppy made, both in design and in graphical appearance. One thing you can't blame Aberdeen for though is being boring, but the crazy imbalance and just dull layout makes me alt-tab to desktop or change server whenever it comes up

Bardia: Gameplay wise it works in about 10% of the map, but I don't see why this map is in FH2 really... to me it's just another custom BF2 map picked from the interwebz. Graphically revolting and simply not that fun to play.

Operation Cobra: Never liked this map because of all the classic design pitfalls it is victim to. A tankmap that isn't about tanking basically. I don't like playing anywhere on this map, the composition and scale is totally off, players are spread out and there is no focus. I also think it has the worst town area in the mod.(no good pathing, looks weird, doesn't provide the intended game play)

Mersa Matruh: getting lost, getting stuck, getting trapped in dead ends, getting HE spammed, getting bored, getting raped.. I don't know but I never enjoyed a full minute of game play on this map. Add to the fact I hate minefields on maps. Could have been an OK infantry-only map only in the town, but the outside is just...empty terrain...makes me sad inside.

Fifth map was really hard!! I had to choose between Alam Halfa, Sidi Rezegh and El Alamein. After some thinking I nailed it down to which maps make me angry, sad and bored when playing... all those three maps make me feel all those emotions, but at least ElAlamein is more boring than Sidi and Alam, so I went for El Alamein, simply not a fun map.

[Biiviz]

Tunis

[djinn]

Arbedeen, feels arcade, works with only a 3rd of its actual size and has no special vehicle or unique aspects.

Cobra, I hate this map because it feels arcade with its steep areas, lack of concealement for tanks and lacking bocage area. It has so many vehicles found no where else and yet it doesnt represent a real battle. The farm should feel like an isolated battle after slogging through bocage country towards the american side, and it doesnt do justice to the quad-50, US tank destroyer and airplanes. I actually wish there'd be another Cobra map with more specific focus.

Operation Supercharge, almost wont miss this map. The only map besides Tunis with dust clouds, it has it at an almost unstrategic location, as with the 88s.
The prize, the town is nothing more than 2 roads, but the dunes do make for fun and unique play.

Bardia is very arcade-looking, but its fun, beautiful and well-designed so I would miss this, but its almost on my list.

for El Alamein, I have some gripes, but it works. I would miss this also, but its also almost on my list of maps that need to go... but we need an El Alamein. After all, we dont have an Omaha.

Here's a tip, focus on battles not operations, unless you have the balancing skill to pull off a Totalize, and lets not take in fanmaps unless they are as good and unique as any official map.

Like, why isnt a map like bloody gulch in, while cobra gets air time?

[Excavus]

Operation Aberdeen - Poorly designed map. Feels unfinished for some reason, just look at the minimap and the roads leading to nowhere. One sided battles and boring gameplay also contribute.

Tunis - Spammy CoD gameplay up in this here map. I hate it because it's infantry only.

Anctoville - Just like Tunis, only with rain.

Battle of Brest - Terrible, boring, spammy, laggy map. CoD gameplay. Every time I've played this map I've ended up being raped by one team. You can't take one step without being killed by a tank or grenade.

Bardia - One of the early maps that isn't up to quality. One sided and unbalanced. Nowhere to hide.

[cannonfodder]

Mersa - There's just nothing I like about it...nothing at all.


It's the only map I wouldn't miss. There's other maps I don't particularly like, but I'd miss them if they weren't there.

[THeTA0123]

Mersa - There's just nothing I like about it...nothing at all.


It's the only map I wouldn't miss. There's other maps I don't particularly like, but I'd miss them if they weren't there.

Amen here

Death to Mersa matruh