It still is a replication. It's not made during WWI, is it?
The same stigma applies to any replica.
Take the automotive scene, muscle cars in particular...
You can build an identical replica of the most desirable muscle car ever built and it will only ever be worth a fraction of the real thing, even though the replica would be a better car having been lovingly restored as opposed to spewed off a production line.
And as aware of that fact as I am, a replica is merely a nice car, whilst the real thing makes me weak at the knees...
@Jimmy: Is that a rep...new Mark IV(?) I see in the background?