Just finished the pilot, I think this has potentional... at first I didn't like the excessive use of lens flare on Galactica, but then again, it probably was to reflect the newness of the Grand Old Lady (kinda like Abrams' Star Trek). Can't wait for SighFie to cancel this sooner than later.
Oh and why is "Machinima" still called that? Last time I checked, "live-action" wasn't anywhere in the definition of machinima.