Alma Halfa Allied bleeding

[IrishReloaded]

Yesterday we played alma halfa at hslan. German forces could cap the first two flag quite fast. But after that Allied started to bleed, which totaly ruined the gameplay. Because german got 200 tickets more, they just defended the 2 capped flags, and let the Allied bleed out.
please change that.
thanks

[Natty]

There is a feedback thread about every map here
http://fhpubforum.warumdarum.de/index.php?board=26.0

I was on the server with you, and I agree 

[Beaufort]

I thought we (the allied) were simply dying faster than the german bleed ? In that case maybe just increase it ?

[djinn]

Yer, i note this issue too... I guess this should be merged with the Alam Halfa 64 Feedback thread, huh?

moderators?

[Knoffhoff]

Are you really talking about the 64 player map? Even though it has been changed by somebody and is quite different from the map I originally created, the code tells me Germans should need to capture 6 flags to start the British bleed.

edit:
It actually is not so much different from the original one, accidentally looked at the Singleplayer version. But it still is 6 flags you need to capture. Even the 32 player version shouldn't start a bleed capturing 2 flags.

[IrishReloaded]

I posted it in here because I have the feeling that noone looks the the map related suggestions.

I'm quite sure they bleeded to hell. I think we got 500 and they got 400 when we capped the flags, and German won with 180 :0

[Knoffhoff]

Then something is not working like it is supposed to be. From the code there shouldn't be any bleed. Maybe messed up serverfiles? I don't know.

[IrishReloaded]

mh okey, strange.

[djinn]

The devs do. Its not so popular with the fans i.e that section of the forum, but the devs do use if for feedback. It just helps to keep data ordered, so the devs know where what is where

[THeTA0123]

Alam halfa needs reworking on the bleed

The allies have to capture the south flag aswel to start the german bleed

Alam halfa is german favored a bit
(then again Operation aberdeen is allied favored)

[Beaufort]

I thought we (the allied) were simply dying faster than the german bleed ? In that case maybe just increase it ?

Hello ?

[IrishReloaded]

Alma halfa is, withouth the strange bleeding, very balanced. You got enough 6 pds, 2pds, bofors.
At Aberdeen Panzer III fight against hordes of Grants, Matildas, Valentines, which are very hard to kill. In addition you dont have any Airsupport or the change to flank them. Also the lack of PzGr40 doest help.

------

@djinn: I posted it here to get also some feedback from other users, and as you can see 2 Devs quite fast found this topic.

I thought we (the allied) were simply dying faster than the german bleed ? In that case maybe just increase it ?

Hello ?

Hello back.
Germans attacked, caped 2 flags, and allied bleeded too with holding 5 flags, that stupid. They should start bleeding when they lost the 2nd line of defence.

[THeTA0123]

its the bleeding wich is the imbalance irish

[Beaufort]

Yeah, the attackers should bleed faster. It is true for many maps.

[IrishReloaded]

its the bleeding wich is the imbalance irish

Alma halfa is, withouth the strange bleeding, very balanced.